Rare Book Monthly

Articles - July - 2012 Issue

Seller Beware: Who really owns it?

A rare 1885 map of Maui had a gift letter, but it wasn't hers to sell. Photo Fitzpatrick & Moffat.

Replevin

McKinney suggested that dealers and collectors would do well to familiarize themselves with the laws relating to "right of replevin.”

Replevin is the legal term which covers recovery of property and deciding who owns what in disputed cases.

Though space here does not allow an adequate discussion of this subject, if you deal or collect things that may once have belonged to a public entity you want know more about replevin.

Under some laws and in some jurisdictions the mere assertion that the item in question was once, even hundreds of years and many owners ago, a public document, is enough for the court to rule in favor of its return.

How the case of the rare Hawaiiana will turn out remains to be seen. As a dealer I wouldn’t touch it or tell my clients about it until I’m positive it is really the seller’s property to sell.

We all know we’re living in a time of transition. What I’ve learned is librarians and archivists are often the worst judges of value and also their procedures for de-acessioning can give you nightmares (See article – De-Acessioning by Dumpster in this month's issue of AE Monthly). Now and in the past items of value were thrown out or given away. When it turns out later the material is rare and valuable, all parties want a piece of the action. The stories can change considerably depending on who is telling the tale.

Beware, you -- the dealer or collector -- can find yourself caught in the middle.

As McKinney suggested I took the time to Google replevin.

Here are a few links that cover the subject from the point of view of the archives and libraries and also from the side of the dealers and collectors.

Though some of these links mention work that is clearly stolen or misappropriated, read it to understand how these situations develop, escalate and play out in the courts.


Replevin Links

A 2004 issue of Railsplitter, a journal for collectors of Lincoln material that examines the issue of replevin from the point of view of the auction house, the collector and the public archive. Probably the most balanced account I found of the hazards involved in acquiring historical documents which once came from a public source. Only part of the newsletter relates to replevin.

www.railsplitter.com/wordpress/PDF/Vol10No1_2.pdf.

Article in Maine Antique Digest c. 2008 about colonial era documents about to be auctioned that were claimed by New Hampshire as “public documents”.

www.maineantiquedigest.com/stories/?id=659.

Review of a 1987 court case concerning ownership of an extensive library of Judaica – did it belong to the religious community or to the heirs of the rabbi?

openjurist.org/833/f2d/431/agudas-chasidei-chabad-of-united-states-v-gourary.

Duke Law Journal 2001, deals primarily with stolen art and good faith purchasers, but contains much information that dealers and collectors of historic material will find relevant.

scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1102&context=dlj.

Art Attack 2006 – Also deals with litigation arising from stolen art and describes situations of interest to those who deal in antiquarian materials of all kinds.

www.abajournal.com/magazine/article/art_attack/.


Archivists, Collectors, Dealers, and Replevin: Case Studies on Private Ownership of Public Documents. This is a hard cover new book published in 2012 listed on Amazon. The listing allows access to sample pages and chapter headings. www.amazon.com/Archivists-Collectors-Dealers-Replevin-Ownership/dp/0810883775.


A 30-page paper c. 2010 on replevin law from an archivist point of view

www.armaedfoundation.org/pdfs/Paper_Mattern_Eleanor_2011.pdf.

Archives & Manuscripts: Law – A 112-page manual published in 1985 by the Society of American Archivists. This a very big pdf file, a small portion deals with replevin. Though the content is somewhat dated, it is still of general interest.

www2.archivists.org/sites/all/files/Archives&Mss-Law.pdf.

AE writer Susan Halas can be reached at wailukusue@gmail.com


Posted On: 2012-07-01 00:00
User Name: arader

Hi Susan

We have a vast stock of great material relating to Hawaii. Hope you will give Alexander Johnson a call in our SF gallery at 415 788 5115 an


Rare Book Monthly

  • Gonnelli
    Auction 51
    Antique prints, paintings and maps
    May 14st 2024
    Gonnelli: Leonard Bramer, The descent from the cross, 1634. Starting price 3200€
    Gonnelli: Gustav Hjalmar de Morner Karel, Rome’s Carnival, 1820. Starting price 1000€
    Gonnelli: Various Authors, Mater Dolorosa, 1700. Starting price 200€
    Gonnelli: Giovanni Battista Piranesi, Carcere Oscura, 1790. Starting price 180€
    Gonnelli: Jan Brueghel, Marine fauna view, 1620 ca. Starting price 28000€
    Gonnelli: Ippolito Scarsella, Mary and Christ with Sant Rocco and Arch-Angel Michele,1615. Starting price 8000€
    Gonnelli: Hans Sebald Beham, Adam and Eve, 1543. Starting price 600€
    Gonnelli: Francesco Burani, Baccanale, 1630. Starting Price 280€
    Gonnelli: Giuseppe Maria Mitelli, Plance from Ventiquattr’ore, 1675. Starting price 800€
    Gonnelli: Giuseppe Angeli, Livorno’s Plan, 1793. Starting price 240€
    Gonnelli: XIV Century Artist, Capital “N” letter, 1350 ca. Starting price 340€
  • Sotheby’s
    Modern First Editions
    Available for Immediate Purchase
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: Winston Churchill. The Second World War. Set of First-Edition Volumes. 6,000 USD
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: A.A. Milne, Ernest H. Shepard. A Collection of The Pooh Books. Set of First-Editions. 18,600 USD
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: Salvador Dalí, Lewis Carroll. Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. Finely Bound and Signed Limited Edition. 15,000 USD
    Sotheby’s
    Modern First Editions
    Available for Immediate Purchase
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: Ian Fleming. Live and Let Die. First Edition. 9,500 USD
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: J.K. Rowling. Harry Potter Series. Finely Bound First Printing Set of Complete Series. 5,650 USD
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: Ernest Hemingway. A Farewell to Arms. First Edition, First Printing. 4,200 USD
  • Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: Isaac Newton on chemistry and matter, and alchemy, Autograph Manuscript, "A Key to Snyders," 3 pp, after 1674. $100,000 - $150,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: Exceptionally rare first printing of Plato's Timaeus. Florence, 1484. $50,000 - $80,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: On the Philosophy of Self-Interest: Adam Smith's copy of Helvetius's De l'homme, Paris, 1773. $40,000 - $60,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: "Magical Calendar of Tycho Brahe" - very rare hermetic broadside. Engraved by Merian for De Bry. c.1618. $30,000 - $50,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: Author's presentation issue of Einstein's proof of Relativity, "Erklärung der Perihelbewegung des Merkur aus der allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie." 1915. $30,000 - $50,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: First Latin edition of Maimonides' Guide for the Perplexed. Paris, 1520. $20,000 - $30,000.
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: De Broglie manuscript on the nature of matter in quantum physics, 3 pp, 1954. $20,000 - $30,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: Tesla autograph letter signed on electricty and electromagnetic theory. 1894. $20,000 - $30,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: Heinrich Hertz scientific manuscript on his mentor Hermann Von Helmholtz, 1891. $20,000 - $30,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: The greatest illustrated work in Alchemy: Micheal Maier's Atalanta Fugiens. Oppenheim, 1618. $30,000 - $50,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: Illustrated Alchemical manuscript, a Mysterium Magnum of the Rosicurcians, 18th-century. $30,000 - $50,000
    Bonhams, Apr. 28 – May 7: Rare Largest Paper Presentation Copy of Newton's Principia, London, 1726. The third and most influential edition. $60,000 - $90,000

Article Search

Archived Articles

Ask Questions